Yes, filming police officers in Pennsylvania is generally legal under the First Amendment, provided the activity does not interfere with law enforcement operations. The U.S. Supreme Court’s 2017 ruling in Glik v. Cunniffe and Pennsylvania’s 2021 Act 14 (amending the Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Act) affirm this right, but local ordinances—such as Philadelphia’s 2023 Police Department Directive 10—impose procedural requirements. Violations may trigger civil penalties under 18 Pa. C.S. § 5703, though enforcement remains inconsistent.
Key Regulations for Filming Police Officers in Pennsylvania
-
First Amendment Protections: Filming police in public spaces is constitutionally protected unless it obstructs official duties. Courts have repeatedly upheld this right, including in Fields v. City of Philadelphia (2019), which rejected claims of “interference” without evidence of actual obstruction.
-
Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Act (18 Pa. C.S. § 5703): Pennsylvania’s two-party consent law does not apply to public recordings, but surreptitious audio recording without consent may violate § 5703. The 2021 amendment clarified that officers have no expectation of privacy in public interactions, though some departments (e.g., Pittsburgh PD) still require verbal notice.
-
Local Ordinances and Departmental Policies: Municipalities like Philadelphia and Pittsburgh mandate that bystanders notify officers before filming, per 2023 directives. Failure to comply may result in temporary detention under municipal codes, though such policies face ongoing legal challenges for chilling free speech.